In a spring post, I spoke about the importance of drawing in the hierarchy of a painting’s success. Value was the second item listed:

1. Drawing
3. Color
4. Edges

In this post I’ll mention a few items regarding the importance of value as a foundational principle of strong work.

Drawing alone can’t fix a piece, the values have to be working. I fully acknowledge that we all know that correct values are important in painting, but the level to which I see even experienced painters (myself included) struggle with this convinces me of the need for constant awareness. As with so many things in life, it is the seemingly simplest things that are the most profound and the most challenging to master.

I break value down into three ideas:


Basically, it comes down to camouflage. Camouflage works because it scatters contrast and breaks up the silhouette of shapes. This makes sense intellectually, but even being aware of the effect, it takes a conscious effort to avoid it happening in artwork. Use this to your advantage and keep things clear in your focal point and more compressed value-wise in other areas.


I can guarantee that nearly any painting I am moved by has a simplified value structure. Compressing and simplifying values to Dark, Medium, and Light will help communicate more clearly and feel more ‘real’. Again, it is seemingly straightforward, but it is surprisingly hard to do well. Thinking of these three distinctions in terms of ‘value families’ instead of only one value option may help.


Saturation isn’t value, but we sure act like it is sometimes. We get sucked in by the color, and we get stupid. I do this all the time (ok, some of the time).

In this final example I’ve shown how I adjusted a piece of photo reference by pushing the surrounding value a little darker so as to read light-on-dark, as it was already leaning in that direction.

Usually, if a color is vibrating your eyes, you’ve got a value problem because the value and saturation are getting too close. This obviously can be used to your advantage in areas that you want to shimmer (such as a sky or mountain) by alternating temperatures slightly while keeping values close. But when you see this shimmer happening all around your main shapes you should pay attention to the alarm bells going off in your head because the shapes aren’t going to read well. Usually getting some distance from your canvas (i.e., across the room), and squinting is a good way to see what’s really going on.

Finally, to quote the great art teacher Leon Parson: “If there is a problem with your painting, it comes down to one of five things (Imagine him holding up a hand and counting down on fingers): value, value, value, value, or value.”

Happy Painting!

Be Sociable, Share!

Upcoming OPA Events

OPA 2018 National Exhibition OPA 2018 National Exhibition
Oil Painters of America’s Twenty-seventh Annual National Exhibition will be held at the Steamboat Art Museum (SAM), Steamboat Springs, Colorado, from June 1 through September 3, 2018. Learn More!
OPA 2016 Summer Online Showcase OPA 2017 Fall Online Showcase
The Fall 2017 Online Showcase is from October 1 - December 15, 2017 and will be open to Associate and Signature members. Learn More!
  • Mary Rose

    I don’t understand the value segment showing 2 images of trees. Is it supposed to show two different value images of the same subject, or is it one image a first stage of the same total image?

    • David Dibble

      Mary, thanks for the question. The first image of trees is just showing the same image with bad and good values to underline the point that drawing alone can’t fix an image.

      The second tree picture is showing a before and after image of how I would adjust a scene to better enhance the natural value structure.

  • Kelli Folsom

    Great article! After 10 years of painting including 4 years at art school I am still learning this lesson and it is imperative….guess I’m a slow student. It’s amazing that the brighter(more saturated) the color is the more we think it’s a lighter value.

    • David Dibble

      Thanks Kelli, I’m glad you enjoyed it. And I’m slow at all of this too, but little by little we’ll get it, as we’re consistent! All the best in your painting.

  • Anne Oborn

    Thank you for your illustrations to teach us. I hope you will share some more!( Sorry, I love both of your”saturation illustrations)

  • Anne Oborn

    I agree with your basic reminders too. Sergei Bongart would often say something similar as he would walk by our canvas, “A, B C’s” !

    • David Dibble

      Thanks Anne, I appreciate the feedback! And yes, focusing on the basics is so important, right?!

  • Robert Yelland

    I love your lesson of Back to Basics : Value, and the point of saturation isn’t value and this shimmer can be distracting. I know I need to step back more and see the painting from a distance. Strong values are powerful. Thanks David.

  • Sally Fraser

    This is a constant struggle and why I don’t see this unless I take a picture with my phone and turn it to B/W can I see the correction I need to make.